Publisher Arkhaven Comics Vox Day explains why the media are attacking JRR Tolkien and why ‘rings of power’ appear to purposely subvert his traditions

Aarkhaven Comics Vox Day’s publisher recently explained why he believes many media outlets, so-called Tolkien academics, Tolkien influencers, and others are attacking J.R.R. Tolkien.

Tyroe Muhafidin as Theo and Nazanin Boniadi as Bronwyn in The Lord of the Rings: The Rings of Power

There is plenty of evidence on the media, so-called Tolkien academics, and others attacking J.R.R. Tolkien. Recently, Deakin University lecturer Helen Young Tolkien accused of racism, anti-Semitism and Orientalism. in conversation.

She was accusing him of writing Orientalism, that the “good” races and genders of Middle-earth are constructed by references to European cultures (particularly northwestern Europe), and that the “bad” races are constructed by Orientalist stereotypes.

Emma Horvath as Erin, Leon and Adam Keene in The Lord of the Rings: The Rings of Power

RELATED: J.R.R. Tolkien ignited a cure for being careless and reckless and shows ‘no visible signs of any appreciation for what it’s about’

Young will go on to claim that he pushes anti-Semitic writings,” Tolkien’s letters show the ways in which real-world ideas about race influenced Middle-earth. He wrote “I think of ‘dwarves’ like Jews: at the same time are citizens and foreigners in their dwellings.”

She explained that she believed this to be anti-Semitic, “there is evidence that he revised his representation of dwarves between The Hobbit and The Lord of the Rings to try to move away from anti-Semitic stereotypes.”

Robert Aramayo as Elrond and Owen Arthur as Prince Doreen IV in The Lord of the Rings: The Rings of Power

Tolkien fan site, not to be confused with, described Tolkien as “waking up” on Twitter, “If you still think Ian McKellen is the worst and that the Catholic Tolkien never agreed, I beg you to read more From Tolkien’s books and letters. Wake up, stand up against hate, embrace all cultures in life and imagination. That’s why his books have been translated in every language.”

Source: The One Ring Twitter

RELATED: Lord Of The Rings fan site says JRR Tolkien, as a Catholic, will celebrate LGBTQ

The site, which recognizes Tolkien as a Catholic, claimed that Tolkien would celebrate LGBTQ because the church celebrates LGBTQ.

They wrote on Twitter, “Follow Tolkien Church, the Church celebrates LGBT people, so I guess surprise is on you.”

Source: Twitter

Ben Sledge Books, Player Features Editor In an article for the site Accusing Tolkien of using anti-Semitic metaphors.

He wrote: “Tolkien’s works are not free from criticism per se. The antisemitic stereotypes in his depiction of dwarves may have been written with good intentions, but describing the Jewish people as ‘gifted’ does not make up for the stereotypes they perpetuate.”

Ismael Cruz Cordova as Arondir and Nazanin Boniadi Bronwyn in The Lord of the Rings: The Rings of Power

RELATED: HarperCollins and Prime Video Compare ‘Bacteria Adhering to Healthy Tissues’ After Revealing New Episodes of Strongly Themed Covers of JRR Tolkien’s The Lord of the Rings

Needless to say, there are numerous examples of media, personalities, and so-called scientists attacking Tolkien and his work.

Dai briefly explains why this happens on his website“It is easy to understand why the Prometheans hated Tolkien so much and why they wanted to destroy his legacy. He knows. He at all He knew. “

And he continued today: “Knowledge of them and their evil and the source of that evil, as evidenced by that.” Dark Herald Review The third episode of The Rangz”.

Morvid Clarke as Galadriel and Lloyd Owen as Elendil in The Lord of the Rings: The Rings of Power

The Dark Herald then briefly summarizes the pharaoh’s ascension to the throne of Númenór, his takeover of Sauron, and Sauron’s further corruption of Ar-Pharazôn which led to Melchor’s private cult and eventual public cult of Melchor involving human sacrifice, Ar-the pharaohs leading the Númenór forces against Valinor , the final Illuvatar intercession that completely wiped out the Númenórean fleet and the massive tidal wave that devastated Númenór.

He specifically paraphrased Tolkien’s description of human sacrifice, which actually read, “Sauron’s power increases daily, and in that temple, with bloodshed and torment
It is a great evil that the people offered a sacrifice to Melchor to release them from death. They often chose their victims from among the faithful. However, it was not openly accused that they would not worship Melchor, the giver of freedom, but a plea against them was that they hated the king and rebelled against him, or that they had plotted against their relatives, and made up lies and poisons. These accusations were mostly false; But those were bitter days and hatred breeds hatred.”

Trystan Gravelle as Pharazôn and Leon Wadham as Kemen
In The Lord of the Rings: The Rings of Power

RELATED: Morfydd Clark attempts to defend drastic changes to JRR Tolkien’s work in ‘The Lord Of The Rings: The Rings Of Power’

The Dark Herald paraphrased this writing, “The entire cult of Morgoth was created by human sacrifice of loyal mortals with the goal of achieving immortality.”

Tolkien mentioned the idea of ​​achieving immortality when speaking extensively of the Númenóreans in a letter to Milton Waldman accompanying his Silmarlion.

He wrote: “They have become so in appearance, and even in powers of reason, they are hardly distinguishable from elves–but they remained mortal, though their reward three years, or more than three times. Their reward is their perdition–or the means of tempting them.”

LONDON, ENGLAND – AUGUST 30: (LR) J.D. Payne, Lindsey Webber and Patrick McKay attend the world premiere of “The Lord of the Rings: The Rings of Power” at Odeon Luxe Leicester Square on August 30, 2022 in London, England. (Photo by Tim B Whitby/Tim B Whitby/Getty Images for Prime Video)

Tolkien later wrote, “Partially foreseeing this, the gods placed a ban on the Númenóreans from the beginning: they should never sail to Eressëa, nor far west from the sight of their land. In all other directions they can go as they please. They must never set foot on the ‘Eternal’ lands.” ”, thereby becoming fascinated by immortality (within the world), which was contrary to their law, or the special torment or gift of the Elvatar (God), which their nature could not in fact bear . . . “

As written in the language Silmarlion“For a wind came down from the east and brought them up. They broke the ban of the Phalar, and they sailed in the forbidden seas, and they went up in war against the dead, to wrest from them eternal life within the circles of the world.”

Cynthia Addai Robinson as Queen Regent Merrill and Morvid Clarke as Galadriel in The Lord of the Rings: Rings of Power

Arkhaven Comics Publisher He then responded to this summary of Tolkien’s writing, “Amazing, isn’t it, that a great fantasy writer could predict the transcendent global technocrats of today in the 1940s? That is because their goals are no different than they were before the dawn of recorded human history: to be like God.”

In fact, Tolkien saw this evil because he also wrote Silmarlionsaid Sauron with many arguments gaining all that the Valar taught; and commanding men to think that in the world, in the East and even in the West, there are many seas and many lands to their victory, where fortune was immeasurable. Yet, if they had to At last they reach the end of those lands and seas, for the old darkness lies behind everything. And out of them is the world. For darkness alone is worship, and its Lord may make other worlds to be gifts to those who serve Him, so that the increase of their power finds no end.”

And he continued, “And the pharaoh said: Who is the Lord of darkness? Then Sauron spoke behind closed doors to the king, and lied, saying: ‘He whose name is not uttered now; for the Valar has deceived you about him, having put forward the name Eru, a ghost invented in the folly of their hearts, Seeking to bind men in servitude to themselves. For they are the revelation of this Eru, who speaks only what they will. But their master will be victorious yet, and will deliver you from this delusion. And his name is Melchor, Lord of all, Grantor of freedom, and He makes you stronger than them.

Morvid Clarke as Galadriel, Lloyd Owen as Elendill, and Cynthia Addai Robinson as Queen Regent Merrill in The Lord of the Rings: The Rings of Power

What do you think of Vox Day’s interpretation of the attacks on Tolkien and the sabotage of his work?

NEXT: YouTuber recounts latest ‘The Rings Of Power’ trailer: unlike anything J.R.R. Tolkien wrote, telling otherwise is a lie

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published.